A field guide to thrifted sport
Secondhand Archive
Vol. 2000s · Indianapolis Colts · #18 Manning

Vintage 2000s Colts

jerseys.

Peyton Manning (#18) was the Colts' quarterback from 1998 to 2011, and his jerseys are the heart of this collection. The uniform is the classic blue or white with shoulder stripes, but it shifted in small ways that help you date one. In 2002 the stripes were cut back to the tops of the shoulders, and in 2004 the blue darkened from royal to "speed blue," the face masks went gray and the socks gained stripes. The Colts won Super Bowl XLI after the 2006 season.

Other numbers include Marvin Harrison (#88), Edgerrin James (#32, 1999–2005) and Reggie Wayne (#87) from 2001. Puma made the on-field jerseys in 2000 and Reebok from 2001, and Reebok held the NFL's exclusive license from 2002 through 2011.

NO. · · 2000S COLTS JERSEYS, BY THE NUMBERS
Years
2000–09
Listed on eBay
1127
Typical ask
$25+

Jump to which one to buy ↓

2000s Indianapolis Colts royal blue Reebok-era jersey number 18 with white shoulder stripes and horseshoe at the collarColts · 2000s
Representative photo, made by AI from real seller photos. Every listing differs. How we make these
NO. 01 · BUYING GUIDE

Which one to buy

From Oct 19, 2026 listings

Manning #18 is on most of these, and Reebok is the right label, since it made Colts jerseys from 2001 through 2011. A Nike tag on a Manning Colts jersey means it was made after he left. Most ask $25–45 delivered. We'd take the Large replica at $32.48, or the stitched Premier for a couple of dollars more. Skip the $111 Manning in 52.

Listed now
1127
Damaged / for parts
0
Typical ask
$25–$45
Full range
$10–$111

Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.

NO. 02 · MARKET SNAPSHOT

For sale on eBay

8 of 1127 listed

Checked . Some may have sold.

Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 19, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ. eBay shows yours before you pay.

Prices change daily. The live eBay search shows everything listed now, including anything new since Oct 19, 2026.

See every listing on eBay →
LOW · $25
TYPICAL · $35
HIGH · $45

typical asks, Oct 19, 2026

price check

a fair price for a fair shirt

NO. 03 · WHAT TO LOOK FOR
  • Shoulder stripes: Check where the stripes end. Before 2002 they wrapped around under the sleeves, and from 2002 they stop on top of the shoulders.
  • Blue shade: Compare the blue against a known piece if it looks off. It darkened from royal to speed blue in 2004.
  • Maker by year: Match the label to the season. Puma made the on-field jerseys in 2000 and Reebok from 2001, and Reebok held the league-wide exclusive from 2002 to 2011.
  • Super Bowl patches: Look for the game patch on jerseys from Super Bowl XLI (2006 season) or XLIV (2009 season). Game patches have been standard since Super Bowl XXXII.
  • Collar shield: Look for the "NFL Equipment" shield on 2002–11 Reebok jerseys. Manning's last Colts season was 2011, so a Manning Colts jersey with Nike's 2012 shield was made after he left.
  • Maker, era and design: Make sure all three agree. A label from a company that didn't make that team's gear in that period, or a design detail from a later season, means the jersey is newer or not what it claims to be.
NO. 04 · REPRINTS & BOOTLEGS
  • Nike-era Colts jerseys (2012 on) look nearly identical to Reebok ones. Check for the Nike label and the newer collar shield, and know that the 2020 update also changed the wordmark and number font.
  • Manning also wore #18 for Denver from 2012 to 2015. Make sure the photos show Colts branding and a Reebok label, not just the number.
  • A blank jersey with numbers added later can look right in photos. Check that the number application matches the rest of the jersey and the labels.
  • Mitchell & Ness sells its NFL Legacy and Authentic throwbacks in numeric sizes (36 S, 40 M, 44 L, 48 XL, 52 2XL, 56 3XL). A numeric size on its own doesn't prove a jersey is old.

Full reproductions guide →

NO. 05 · SIZING

Measure, don't trust the tag. Most Colts jerseys from the decade are Reebok. Reebok made every licensed NFL jersey from 2002 through 2011, but tag sizes still run differently between jerseys, and plenty of listings are mis-sized. Look for a tape measure laid across the chest in the photos, or pit-to-pit (armpit to armpit, laid flat) and back length (collar to hem) in the description. Measure a jersey you own the same way and compare. If a listing shows neither, message the seller for those two numbers before you buy.

Vintage sizing guide →

the 2000s colts
18
worn by · Manning
the

Manning

era, 2000–2009

Manning, Harrison, Wayne and Dungy. Super Bowl XLI won in the Miami rain.

NO. 06 · IN THE DESIGN ARCHIVE

Looking for one design in particular? The archive files every Colts design we found on eBay on its own page, with all its past examples.

Indianapolis Colts · 17 designs →2006 AFC Championship →

NO. 07 · RELATED COLLECTIONS
NO. 08 · FIELD NOTES

Is a Peyton Manning Colts jersey Puma or Reebok?

Most from the decade are Reebok. Puma made the Colts' on-field jerseys in 2000 and Reebok from 2001, and Reebok then held the NFL's exclusive license from 2002 through 2011.

How do I tell a 2000s Colts jersey from a post-2012 Nike one?

Read the label and the collar, because the design barely changed. Reebok plus the "NFL Equipment" shield means 2002–11. Nike plus the redesigned shield means 2012 or later.

Which players are on 2000s Colts jerseys?

Peyton Manning (#18, 1998–2011) first, then Marvin Harrison (#88, 1996–2008), Edgerrin James (#32, 1999–2005) and Reggie Wayne (#87, 2001–14).

What changed on Colts uniforms in 2004?

The blue darkened from royal to speed blue, the face masks went from blue back to the traditional gray, and two white stripes were added to the socks. The jersey design itself stayed the same.

Read the full buying guide →