Vintage 2000s Colts
Peyton Manning (#18) was the Colts' quarterback from 1998 to 2011, and his jerseys are the heart of this collection. The uniform is the classic blue or white with shoulder stripes, but it shifted in small ways. In 2002 the stripes were cut back to the tops of the shoulders, and in 2004 the blue darkened from royal to "speed blue," the face masks went gray and the socks gained stripes. The Colts won Super Bowl XLI after the 2006 season.
Other numbers include Marvin Harrison (#88), Edgerrin James (#32, 1999–2005) and Reggie Wayne (#87) from 2001. Puma made the on-field jerseys in 2000 and Reebok from 2001; Reebok held the NFL's exclusive license from 2002 through 2011.
Colts · 2000sWhich one to buy
1,100 Colts jerseys turn up in a Reebok search, the deepest of the three 2000s collections, with most asking $25–50 delivered and Peyton Manning #18 on the bulk of them, plus Marvin Harrison, Reggie Wayne and Dallas Clark. Reebok is the correct label for the decade, as the NFL's sole jersey supplier from 2002 to 2011: plain replicas have screen-printed numbers, Premier is stitched, and Authentic has sewn numbers and a numeric size (48 = L, 52 = XL), which here costs barely more than a replica. A Super Bowl XLI patch, from the 2006 title season, is the collectible detail to look for, while Nike or 'NFL Team Apparel' tags mean a post-2012 jersey. Red flags: a Super Bowl XLI Vinatieri at about $82 and a Marvin Harrison at $29, both from sellers whose feedback wasn't captured. Budget buyers should take the $16 Manning in Medium, first-time buyers the $36 Manning in XL, and collectors the $48 Reebok Authentic Manning in 52.
- Listed now
- 1100
- Damaged / for parts
- 0
- Typical ask
- $25–$50
- Full range
- $10–$75
Cheapest$15.99est. deliveredA Reebok Peyton Manning #18 in blue, Medium, for about $16 delivered with Best Offer from a 99.3% seller, the lowest price here. At this price it's likely the screened replica, so ask for close-ups of the numbers, a tag photo and pit-to-pit.
Vintage Reebok Peyton Manning #18 Indianapolis Colts Blue Jersey Mediu
View on eBay →$15.99 est. delivered
Best value$37.09est. deliveredA Super Bowl XLI Joseph Addai, the Colts' rookie back that season, for about $37 delivered with Best Offer from a 99.7% seller, inside the $25–50 band. The patch is the collectible detail, so ask for a photo of it, plus the size, which is cut off.
vintage Reebok Super Bowl XLI Joseph Addai Indianapolis Colts jersey s
View on eBay →$37.09 est. delivered
Best for beginners$35.59est. deliveredA Reebok Peyton Manning in blue XL for about $36 delivered with Best Offer from a 100% seller: era-correct, a common size and mid-band. Ask whether the numbers are screened or stitched, and for pit-to-pit and photos of them.
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Jersey Reebok NFL XL Blue Vintage #1
View on eBay →$35.59 est. delivered
Collector's pick$47.65est. deliveredA Reebok Authentic Manning #18 in 52 (XL), titled 'Captain', for about $48 delivered with Best Offer from a 100% seller, barely more than a replica. Ask for photos of the sewn numbers, the tag and the captain patch the title implies.
Vintage Peyton Manning Colts Reebok Authentic Jersey 52 Captain #18
View on eBay →$47.65 est. delivered
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 3, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ; eBay shows your exact total before you buy.
Live on eBay right now
Snapshot captured — listings may have ended.
Delivered prices include shipping as eBay quoted it to a US address on Oct 3, 2026. Many sellers charge by distance, so your total may differ; eBay shows your exact total before you buy.
- Used
- Cheapest
Vintage Reebok Peyton Manning #18 Indianapolis Colts Blue Jersey Mediu
$15.99est. delivered
$10.00 + $5.99 shipping
Buy It Now$10.00
Offers accepted
This seller takes offers, and sellers often accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Good buy
Reebok Peyton Manning #18 in blue, Medium, for about $16 delivered from a 99.3% seller, the cheapest Manning here.
Seller: kg21man
99.3% positive
View on eBay →Used - Used
- Best value
vintage Reebok Super Bowl XLI Joseph Addai Indianapolis Colts jersey s
$37.09est. delivered
$30.00 + $7.09 shipping
Buy It Now$30.00
Offers accepted
This seller takes offers, and sellers often accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Good buy
Reebok Super Bowl XLI Joseph Addai for about $37 delivered from a 99.7% seller; confirm the patch is on it.
Seller: chrishuov-0
99.7% positive
View on eBay →Used - Used
- Best for beginners
Peyton Manning Indianapolis Colts Jersey Reebok NFL XL Blue Vintage #1
$35.59est. delivered
$24.99 + $10.60 shipping
Buy It Now$24.99
Offers accepted
This seller takes offers, and sellers often accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Good buy
Reebok Manning in blue XL for about $36 delivered from a 100% seller, mid-band in a common size.
Seller: currly2710p
100% positive
View on eBay →Used - Used
- Collector's pick
Vintage Peyton Manning Colts Reebok Authentic Jersey 52 Captain #18
$47.65est. delivered
$37.99 + $9.66 shipping
Buy It Now$37.99
Offers accepted
This seller takes offers, and sellers often accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Good buy
Reebok Authentic Manning #18 in 52 (XL), titled 'Captain', for about $48 delivered from a 100% seller, barely more than a replica.
Seller: letix_memorabilia
100% positive
View on eBay →Used 
UsedVintage Reebok Indianapolis Colts Jersey Mens 2XL Blue Anthony Gonzale
$19.20est. delivered
$13.00 + $6.20 shipping
Buy It Now$13.00
Our take
Reebok Anthony Gonzalez in 2XL for about $19 on Buy It Now from a 99.8% seller; cheap, but Gonzalez was a minor receiver.
Seller: briabargains
99.8% positive
View on eBay →Used
UsedVintage Reebok Indianapolis Colts NFL Jersey Mens Medium Blue Peyton M
$37.51est. delivered
$29.99 + $7.52 shipping
Buy It Now$29.99
Our take
Reebok Manning in blue Medium for about $38 on Buy It Now from a 99.4% seller; fine, but the $16 Medium Manning covers the same ground for less.
Seller: jerseys_plus
99.4% positive
View on eBay →Used
Used- Check the seller
Vintage Y2K Reebok Indianapolis Colts Marvin Harrison #88 Jersey Men X
$29.17est. delivered
$22.49 + $6.68 shipping
Buy It Now$22.49
Offers accepted
This seller takes offers, and sellers often accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Heads-up: check the seller
Reebok Marvin Harrison #88 for about $29 delivered, a fair price, but the seller's feedback wasn't captured.
Seller: unknown
View on eBay →Used
Used- Check the seller
- Priced high
Adam Vinatieri Indianapolis Colts Super Bowl XLI Reebok NFL Jersey Lar
$81.61est. delivered
$74.99 + $6.62 shipping
Buy It Now$74.99
Offers accepted
This seller takes offers, and sellers often accept less than the asking price.
Fine if you might miss it? Send an offer first. Someone else can still buy it while you wait for a reply.
Want it for sure? Use Buy It Now.
Heads-up: priced high
Super Bowl XLI Vinatieri in Large at about $82 delivered, well above the band, from a seller whose feedback wasn't captured.
Seller: unknown
View on eBay →Used
Prices and availability change daily. The full, current search on eBay shows every matching listing, including new ones since Oct 3, 2026.
See all current listings on eBay →typical asks, Oct 3, 2026
a fair price for a fair shirt
- Shoulder stripes: before 2002 the stripes wrapped around under the sleeves. From 2002 they stop on top of the shoulders.
- Blue shade: the blue darkened from royal to speed blue in 2004. Compare against a known piece if the shade looks off.
- Maker by year: Puma made the on-field jerseys in 2000 and Reebok from 2001. Reebok held the league-wide exclusive from 2002 to 2011.
- Super Bowl patches: game patches have been standard since Super Bowl XXXII, so jerseys from Super Bowl XLI (2006 season) or XLIV (2009 season) can carry the game patch.
- Collar shield: 2002–11 Reebok jerseys carry the "NFL Equipment" shield. Manning's last Colts season was 2011, so a Manning Colts jersey with Nike's 2012 shield was made after he left.
- Make sure the maker, the era and the design agree. A label from a company that did not make that team's gear in that period, or a design detail from a later season, means the jersey is newer or not what it claims to be.
- Nike-era Colts jerseys (2012 on) look nearly identical to Reebok ones. Check for the Nike label and the newer collar shield; the 2020 update also changed the wordmark and number font.
- Manning also wore #18 for Denver from 2012 to 2015. Make sure the photos show Colts branding and a Reebok label, not just the number.
- Customized jerseys: a blank jersey with numbers added later can look right in photos. Check that the number application matches the rest of the jersey and the labels.
- Mitchell & Ness sells its NFL Legacy and Authentic throwbacks in numeric sizes (36 S, 40 M, 44 L, 48 XL, 52 2XL, 56 3XL), so a numeric size on its own does not prove a jersey is old.
Most Colts jerseys from the decade are Reebok. Reebok made every licensed NFL jersey from 2002 through 2011, but tag sizes can still run differently between jerseys, so don't rely on the letter size alone. Ask for pit-to-pit (armpit to armpit, laid flat) and back length from collar to hem, and compare them with a jersey you own. Tagged sizes vary by maker and era, and many listings are mis-sized.
Manning
Manning, Harrison, Wayne and Dungy. Super Bowl XLI won in the Miami rain.
Looking for one specific design? The archive files every Colts design we found on eBay, one page each, with all its past examples.
Vintage 1960s–70s Colts sweatshirts
Vintage 1960s–70s Colts jerseys
Vintage 1980s Colts sweatshirts
Vintage 2000s Patriots jerseys
Vintage 2000s Falcons jerseys
Vintage 2000s Packers jerseys
Puma or Reebok Manning jersey?
Puma made the Colts' on-field jerseys in 2000, Reebok from 2001. Reebok then held the NFL's exclusive license from 2002 through 2011, so most Manning jerseys you see from the decade are Reebok.
How do I tell a 2000s Colts jersey from a post-2012 Nike?
The design barely changed, so read the label and the collar. Reebok plus the "NFL Equipment" shield means 2002–11. Nike plus the redesigned shield means 2012 or later.
Whose jerseys are these?
Peyton Manning (#18, 1998–2011) first, then Marvin Harrison (#88, 1996–2008), Edgerrin James (#32, 1999–2005) and Reggie Wayne (#87, 2001–14).
What changed in 2004?
The blue darkened from royal to speed blue, the face masks went from blue back to the traditional gray, and two white stripes were added to the socks. The jersey design itself stayed the same.