A field guide to thrifted sport
Secondhand Archive
Vol. 60s–70s · Buffalo Bills · #32 Simpson

Vintage 1960s–70s Bills

sweatshirts.

Vintage 1960s–70s Buffalo Bills sweatshirts, from the O.J. years (1969–1977). AFL titles in '64 and '65, then the Juice: 2,003 yards in 1973 behind the Electric Company.

In 1962, a standing red buffalo on a white helmet became the logo as the team switched to red, white and blue. In 1974, the charging blue buffalo with a red streak replaced the standing buffalo.

NO. · · 1960S–70S BILLS SWEATSHIRTS, BY THE NUMBERS
Years
1960–79
Garment
sweatshirt
Rough value
$91+
32
Simpson · #32
CREWNECK'72
60s–70s · Sweatshirts
vol. 60s–70s
NO. 01 · ON EBAY NOW

We haven't been through this collection's eBay listings. Here's the search we'd use, and the checklist below will help you judge what you find.

Search eBay →
LOW · $91
TYPICAL · $203
HIGH · $508

rough guide, not an appraisal

price check

a fair price for a fair shirt

NO. 02 · WHAT TO LOOK FOR
  • Old team names: Look for the Boston Patriots (renamed New England in 1971), the Dallas Texans (moved to Kansas City as the Chiefs in 1963), the Baltimore Colts and the Houston Oilers.
  • Short-lived logos: Look for the Bills' standing buffalo (through 1973), the Giants' lowercase "ny" (1961-74), the Bears' white wishbone C (orange from 1974) and the Broncos' pre-1968 bucking horse.
  • Rochester labels: A Champion label that credits Rochester, N.Y., fits this era. The company was based there until Sara Lee bought it in 1989, so the address doesn't prove the date on its own.
  • Tag: Read the maker, country of origin and fiber content first. A Made in USA tag fits the 80s and early 90s better than the 2000s.
  • Team timeline: Match the logo, colors and city name to the team's history. All three should fit the era the seller claims.
the 60s–70s bills
32
worn by · Simpson
the

O.J.

era, 1969–1977

AFL titles in '64 and '65, then the Juice: 2,003 yards in 1973 behind the Electric Company.

NO. 03 · IN THE DESIGN ARCHIVE

Looking for one design in particular? The archive files every Bills design we found on eBay on its own page, with all its past examples.

Buffalo Bills · 26 designs →

NO. 04 · RELATED COLLECTIONS
NO. 05 · FIELD NOTES

How can I tell a 1960s–70s Bills sweatshirt is original and not a modern reissue?

Start with the tag. The maker and the country it was made in should fit the 1960s–70s. Start with the buffalo and the helmet. A standing bison is 1962-73, or a throwback from 2005 on. The charging buffalo on a white helmet is 1974-83 and on a red helmet 1984 on, and dark navy with gray points to 2002 or later.

How does a vintage sweatshirt fit?

Measure, don't trust the tag size. Vintage sweatshirts were cut differently from today's and cotton blends shrink in the wash. Look for pit-to-pit and length in the photos or description, and compare them with a sweatshirt you own.

Read the full buying guide →